Group Discussion - 3

[kartik]

Gd taker: Hello everyone
chaitali thakker: hiii
vyankatesh rathi: HI
vesh2good4u: hiee
vyankatesh rathi: SEE MY EFFECT
Gd taker: We will start with the gd now
PRERNA JAIN: hi everone!
Gd taker: Please introduce yourself ... your name, educational background and work experience (if any )
chaitali thakker: lets start the gd
Gd taker: Please avoid using short forms in Group Discussion
Gd taker: Introduce yourself one by one please
vesh2good4u: HI, I M VISHAL (VESH), F.Y.B.M.S, NO WORK EXP
vyankatesh rathi: VYANKATESH RATHI , T.Y.B.M.S, SMT.C.H,M COLLEGE, ULHASNAGAR
PRERNA JAIN: I m PRERNA in F.Y.B.M.S. frm Mithibai col, Vile Parle
chaitali thakker: CHAITALI OF TY BMS FROM SARAF COLLEGE.. AND NO WORK EXPERIENCE..
vesh2good4u: VESH FROM RIZVI MGMT INSTITUTE
Gd taker: Okay.
vyankatesh rathi: LETS START
vesh2good4u: K
Gd taker: The topic for todays gd is : Concessions to women
vesh2good4u: CAN U ELABORATE ON DAT
vesh2good4u: IN WHICH SECTIONS
Gd taker: Start ... The GD will end at 3.50 sharp
vyankatesh rathi: CONCESSIONS ON WOMEN
Gd taker: all sections @ vesh..
vesh2good4u: K
vyankatesh rathi: CONCESSIONS TO WOMEN SHULD BE GIVEN TILL 12TH STANDARD
vyankatesh rathi: BUT NOT AFTER THT
vesh2good4u: I DONT'T AGREE
chaitali thakker: women empowerment has began
vesh2good4u: NO CONCESSIONS
vesh2good4u: I SAY
vyankatesh rathi: Y
chaitali thakker: concessions are given everywhr
chaitali thakker: everywhere
vesh2good4u: BUT UPTO A EXTENT ITS FINE
vesh2good4u: I MEAN TO SAY UPTO SCHOOL
chaitali thakker: say railway or college fees...
vesh2good4u: NOT AFTER DAT
vyankatesh rathi: THTS WHT I SAID CONCESSIONS SHULD BE GIVENN UPTO 12TH
chaitali thakker: i dont think so..
PRERNA JAIN: i think since India is on the developind stage, it should give equal opportunities to both men as well as women
vesh2good4u: DATS WAT I MTRYING TO SAY
vyankatesh rathi: WHT U MEAN BY EQUAL OPPURTUNITIES
PRERNA JAIN: because our country is good in human resource
chaitali thakker: do u think there are enough opportunities for women.. i dont agree
vesh2good4u: I AGREE
vyankatesh rathi: CONCESSIONS SHULD BE GIVEN OR NOT
vesh2good4u: NOPE
chaitali thakker: yes it should be given
vyankatesh rathi: VESH UR COUNTTERIN UR POINT
chaitali thakker: we just say equal rights but do we all folllow
vyankatesh rathi: Y NOT
vesh2good4u: WAT MAKE YOU'LL THINK DAT WOMEN DONT HAVE EQUAL RIGHTS IN OUR SOCIETY
vyankatesh rathi: WE FOLLOW EQUAL RIGHTS
vesh2good4u: AFCORCE THEY HAVE
chaitali thakker: i hope we have atopic of concession to women
chaitali thakker: we are changing track
vyankatesh rathi: YA WOMEN TODAY HAV MORE RIGHTS THN MEN
vesh2good4u: YUP
vyankatesh rathi: U DAIS
chaitali thakker: no short forms please
vyankatesh rathi: U SAID ABOUT EQUALITY
vyankatesh rathi: SO I HAD TO SAY
tweetybird_303 has joined the conference.
chaitali thakker: just in written laws... rights are more for women and not practically
PRERNA JAIN: thts true!
vesh2good4u: ACCORDING to me men & women are treated eually
vyankatesh rathi: ABOUT CONCESSIONS WOMEN SHULD BE GIVEN TILL 12TH AND NOT AFTER THT
vesh2good4u: so y concessions for women
PRERNA JAIN: y r u talkin about only 12th again & again?
chaitali thakker: today concessions are provided everywhere but there is a need of it
vyankatesh rathi: B'COZ I THNK THTS THE LIMIT THT THE WOMEN SHULD HAV CONCESSIONS
PRERNA JAIN: do u think there shud b no scope 4 women after tht?
vyankatesh rathi: SCOPE HAS NUTHIN TO DO WTH CONCESSIONS
vesh2good4u: THEY R independent adter dat
vesh2good4u: after dat poiny
vyankatesh rathi: DO U THNK CONCESIONS CAN LEAD TO BROADER SCOPE
vesh2good4u: u cannot hold one's hand uptill the end
PRERNA JAIN: I wud lik 2 mk u aware even today girls r not encouraged in their families to go & hv education
chaitali thakker: y the concession of getting a seat in bus crowded
vesh2good4u: some communities
chaitali thakker: ya true...
vesh2good4u: not all religion
Ranjan Ghosh has joined the conference.
vyankatesh rathi: WELL IN MY FAMILY MY SIS IS MORE EDUCATD THN I EVER WILL BE
vesh2good4u: the bus seat is fine
chaitali thakker: one example( practical) a girl who stood 1st in college
PRERNA JAIN: tht depends on u
vyankatesh rathi: THR R MANY
PRERNA JAIN: how much u wnt 2 learn
Ranjan Ghosh: could u tel me the topic
vyankatesh rathi: SEE ABOUT 1998 10 TH RESULTS
chaitali thakker: just told home that she stood 1st.. u know wht was reply from parents...
vyankatesh rathi: WHT
chaitali thakker: so wht u just keep certificates on terrace or wht and they tore the marksheet..
vesh2good4u: as long as the seats in bus and caoches in train goes its fine but when it comes to fees everyone should be treated the same way
vyankatesh rathi: WELL NOW UR CHANGIN THE TOPIC
vesh2good4u: me?
vyankatesh rathi: CHAITALI
vesh2good4u: what are you view guys
Ranjan Ghosh: could anyone tel me the gd topic
vesh2good4u: on the fees structure for women
Ranjan Ghosh: plz
chaitali thakker: there are cases where girls are more in home than boys so to educate girls there is concession in fees
tweetybird_303 has left the conference.
PRERNA JAIN has left the conference.
Gd taker: Please dont use the MIC
chaitali thakker: i m prooving my point on girls condition..
vesh2good4u: DATS A DIFFRENT TOPIC
vesh2good4u: try dat next sunday
vyankatesh rathi: BUT GIVIN CONCESSIONS IN RAILWAYS AND OTHERS IS NOT APPROPRIATE
chaitali thakker: no in this there must be aview of it..
chaitali thakker: y so.. gaurav
vyankatesh rathi: BUT Y GIVIN CONCESIONS IN RAILWAYS
vyankatesh rathi: GRLS FRM WELL TO DO FAMILY AVAIL THE FACILTIY OF CONCESSIONS WHILE BOYS FRM POORER SECTION CANT AFFORD THE PASSES
chaitali thakker: we belong to our tradition where females and males dont sit together not even husband and wife.. so for female there is a concessions
vyankatesh rathi: BUT THT IS CHANGIN
vyankatesh rathi: U ONLY SAID U WANTD EQUALITY
Ranjan Ghosh has left the conference.
vyankatesh rathi: HOW DO CONCESSIONS PROVE UR POINT OF EQUALITY
chaitali thakker: gaurav i hope v r discussing the topic of concession for women... right
vyankatesh rathi: YA
vyankatesh rathi: THTS WHT I SAID
vesh2good4u: gd can we have more participants
chaitali thakker: no.. i m saying there must be sufficient concession to women
vesh2good4u: dats wat upto a extent
vesh2good4u: dats upto high school
vyankatesh rathi: I HAV SAID THT BEFORE. CONCESSIONS SHULD BE GIVEN TILLL 12TH
Gd taker: no.. gd wil end in 10 mins.. no new participants please
chaitali thakker: no... i dont agree..
vesh2good4u: Y?
vyankatesh rathi: YA
vyankatesh rathi: Y
chaitali thakker: y a girl should study upto 12th only
vyankatesh rathi: WHO SAID STUDY ONLY UPTO 12TH.
vesh2good4u: yeah
vesh2good4u: who said dat
vyankatesh rathi: BUT CONCESSIONS SHULD BE UPTO 12TH
vesh2good4u: yeah
vyankatesh rathi: CONCESSIONS LIKE RAILWAYS, BUSSES ETC SHULD NOT NOT BE GIVEN FURTHER
vesh2good4u: different seats for women its fine
chaitali thakker: than in many families and many cases if government give concession thn they can study so...
vyankatesh rathi: AND FEES CONCESIONS SHULD BE PROIVDED ON CERATIN BASIS
vesh2good4u: and i think the fees should be provided to girls from not so richer families
vyankatesh rathi: BUT THN IT CAN ALSO BE SAID ABOUT BOYS THN. NOT MANY FAMILIES R IN THE POSITION TO PROVIDE THM WITH MONEY
chaitali thakker: see its on the girl to adopt concession or not..
vyankatesh rathi: CHAITALI
chaitali thakker: ya gaurav
vesh2good4u: but still girls adopt it
vyankatesh rathi: WHCH GRL WONT ACCEPT CONCESSION GIVEN TO HER
vyankatesh rathi: WULD U DENY IT IF GIVEN CONCESSION
vesh2good4u: nope
chaitali thakker: surely i would not take concession
vyankatesh rathi: UR JUST ONE
chaitali thakker: as i m capable of paying my expenses..
chaitali thakker: i can prove u
vyankatesh rathi: OTHERS DONT THNK SO
chaitali thakker: i m in girls coll
vesh2good4u: i agree
chaitali thakker: thr are many concession but limited numbers...
chaitali thakker: so many r not getting who need it..
vyankatesh rathi: B'COA ITS A GRLS COLLEGE AND THRS COMPETITION FOR GETTIN SEATS
chaitali thakker: many dont take as they dont need it
vesh2good4u: i dont see anyone denying a concession
chaitali thakker: its not ony my coll
vyankatesh rathi: "so many r not getting who need it.." IT S UR WRDIN CHAITALI
chaitali thakker: ya every1 wants it
chaitali thakker: but there should be sufficient amount and needy should get it
vyankatesh rathi: THTS WHT I SAID Y WULD ANYONE DENY CONCESSION GIVE TO THM
chaitali thakker: ya gaurav its y wording
vesh2good4u: for dat there should be a proper rule for providing concessions
chaitali thakker: see u r getting concession on railway pass from ur coll
vyankatesh rathi: WE R CHANGIN TRACKS
chaitali thakker: right???
vyankatesh rathi: YA
vyankatesh rathi: BUT ID ONT USE IT
chaitali thakker: no i m proving my example
chaitali thakker: y u r taking? dont take give to others...
vyankatesh rathi: WE CANT GIVE IT TO OTHERS
chaitali thakker: u r exception and not all
vyankatesh rathi: NONE OF MY FRNDZ TAKE CONCESSIONS
chaitali thakker: if u r not taking tht ur coll frnds can avail it
chaitali thakker: ur group is exception than and not all
vyankatesh rathi: WE CANT TRANSFER THT CONCESSION
vesh2good4u: gd taker is this a gd or a debate
chaitali thakker: i know...tht was just example..
chaitali thakker: wht u think veshu?
Gd taker: its the way you take it .. supposed to be a gd.. my views will be put on MP later
vyankatesh rathi: THTS WHT I SSAID NO GRL WULD DENY THE CONCESSION GIVEN TO HER.
vesh2good4u: PROPER rule for concesion should be made
vyankatesh rathi: EVEN IF SHE IS FRM WELL TODO FAMILY
Gd taker: you guyz have 3 minutes left
vyankatesh rathi: YA
chaitali thakker: ok
vyankatesh rathi: WHT U SAY
chaitali thakker: so i conclude my point that concession specially to girls should be ther
vyankatesh rathi: ELABORATE 'SPECIALLY'
Gd taker: Ok.. time UP
chaitali thakker: specially means to females of all ages
chaitali thakker: thank you
vyankatesh rathi: OK
vesh2good4u: i conclude by saying it again irrespective of anyone listening to it or not "proper rules for concessions shuld be made"
Gd taker: I ask each one of you to conclude the GD and your opinion in 2 lines
vyankatesh rathi: THANK U
Gd taker: I ask each one of you to conclude the GD and your opinion in 2 lines
vesh2good4u: i conclude by saying it again irrespective of anyone listening to it or not "proper rules for concessions shuld be made"
chaitali thakker: all ages females concession should be there and it should be available to every women in india..
vyankatesh rathi: CONCESSIONS SHULD BE GIVEN TO WOMENS TILL 12TH AND FURTHER DEPENDING UPON THR STATUS
vesh2good4u: thank u
vyankatesh rathi: THANK U
chaitali thakker: thanku
Gd taker: Ok.. thank you everyone
chaitali thakker: thank you
Gd taker: results will be put up on MP forums in 2 days time

[karma]

ya right chaitali !!!! first women brag about giving equal status... like men.. then ask for concession too.. gr8 going

[nick18_in]

Hi all...

Really sorry for the delay in reply...

I think the gd went to extent well..

I would take in people for the next round in this way --->>
Chaitali , vyanketesh , Prerna, Vesh...

I would like to people to give personal examples.. but avoid to impress more on it.. that might create problems during the original gd.. as there are many more people in there..

Also, only some aspects, rather a few aspects of the concessions were discussed.. people could have bought it in more & more ideas for the same too..

Budget is coming near by.. there could be some points given for the same..

I would like more people to be involved in the gd.. as it will spread more & more knowledge amongst you people..

take care