GD-2 --->> PSU Disinvestment.This is a discussion on GD-2 --->> PSU Disinvestment. within the Group Discussions Online Archive ( GD ) forums, part of the CAT, XAT, MAT, CET, JMET and other Indian MBA Entrance Exams category; Hi all..
For this gd there were only 3 people... so it dint took much time to declare the same...
...  | | | | | MP future GURU Institute: University of Mumbai
Status: Offline Posts: 1,249 Management Paradise Rupees.: 20,582 Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Mumbai | GD-2 --->> PSU Disinvestment. -
February 5th, 2006
Hi all..
For this gd there were only 3 people... so it dint took much time to declare the same...
I would again request people to be on time to enter the gd & please read the guideliness before coming in...
---------->>>>>
Gd taker: we start with intro.. frm all the people.. as education, exp..
snowman2cool: Rochit from TYBMS Lala College
vyankatesh rathi: vyankatesh from TYBMS SMT.C.H.M COLLEGE, ULHASNAGAR
PRERNA JAIN: Prerna from FYBMS MITHIBAI COLLEGE, VILE PARLE
Gd taker: the topic for todays gd is --->> PSU DISINVESTMENT
vyankatesh rathi: psu disinvestment
PRERNA JAIN: I think this year the govt. should concentrate on tha PSU disinvestment coz disinvestment in PSU helps in deepening and widening the domestic capital market
vyankatesh rathi: can u elaborate
vyankatesh rathi: prerna
PRERNA JAIN: Also, it will help in releasing huge amount of money that can be used for social as well as infrastructure projects.
snowman2cool: newayz Psu disinvestment has two sides
vyankatesh rathi: all things hav two sides
vyankatesh rathi: but disinvstng profitable units will not help
snowman2cool: psu disinvestment is like our government sold the navratnas the main companies which made profits to private players
vyankatesh rathi: thts wht i said
PRERNA JAIN: so what!
snowman2cool: so the governmet is controlling them we are at the rpivate players mercy
PRERNA JAIN: but u shld also look to th =ve points of it.
snowman2cool: positive or negative
PRERNA JAIN: +ve*
snowman2cool: positive or negative
snowman2cool: ok
vyankatesh rathi: wht are positive points
snowman2cool: more productivity
PRERNA JAIN: price reduction
snowman2cool: increased profits
PRERNA JAIN: better quality
snowman2cool: increased competitiveness
vyankatesh rathi: but wht if thy turn blind eye
vyankatesh rathi: to all these
PRERNA JAIN: reduced monopoly
vyankatesh rathi: and use it for their benefits
snowman2cool: but
snowman2cool: there is a catch
vyankatesh rathi: wht
PRERNA JAIN: this has never happened yet
vyankatesh rathi: it may be going on
snowman2cool: we are increasing our economy by doing so
vyankatesh rathi: its just its not yet publishd
snowman2cool: but there are staff reduction...
vyankatesh rathi: ya
vyankatesh rathi: thy cuttin down jobs
snowman2cool: more unemployment
vyankatesh rathi: see the negative points
snowman2cool: we are at thier mercy
vyankatesh rathi: whts the use of growin econmy ifits does not benefit the people
snowman2cool: we want power then calll reliance
snowman2cool: reliance cuts power wait for them
snowman2cool: government does not cut power !!
vyankatesh rathi: and thy dont respond fast
PRERNA JAIN: do u think if the govt. gives employment, then these employed people r workin properly?
vyankatesh rathi: govt does cut power
snowman2cool: see employment is another issue
vyankatesh rathi: who told private employees wrk properly
PRERNA JAIN: they do work coz they hv pressure of the work to get done from their superiors.
snowman2cool: but they hav the responsibility.... i hav seen public company employees getting things done
PRERNA JAIN: howeverin th public sec. they dont.
snowman2cool: working is not the issue
vyankatesh rathi: but if superiors wrk for thwir benefit thn whts the use disinvstn profitable units
snowman2cool: the main thing is
vyankatesh rathi: psu shuld not be disinvstd
PRERNA JAIN: ok then y do u think the govt. transferred the energy sector to ambani's?
vyankatesh rathi: just their shuld be a proper management in those units so as thy wrk properly
snowman2cool: psu divestment is harmful to our society becos as private player bring in efficiency they cut down staff which leads to unemployment..... our INDIA is overspilling... people are more.... they need food
PRERNA JAIN: bcoz private sector gives better results thn th public ones
snowman2cool: we need labour intensive companies
snowman2cool: rethe yhan machine intensive
vyankatesh rathi: i agree snowoman
PRERNA JAIN: but i dont
vyankatesh rathi: and prerna thts wht im sayin
vyankatesh rathi: see reliance do not provide electricity properly
snowman2cool: psu's no thwe responsibility towards the society.. the public.. they are answerable to the public
but private players are not answerable to anyoone ...... THIS IS THE POINT
PRERNA JAIN: it does
vyankatesh rathi: well thn y do we hear news
vyankatesh rathi: about irregular supply of electricty
vyankatesh rathi: and overchrgin of bills
vyankatesh rathi: prerna
PRERNA JAIN: then y wer there power failures in the rural areas?
snowman2cool: listen i live in mumbai i dont experience any problems regarding anything whatsoever but look at a different point of view look at thane etc
PRERNA JAIN: after when reliance has entered , it has made an attempt to reduce this
vyankatesh rathi: power failures are causd due to ever incrsin dmnd of electricity
snowman2cool: ya
PRERNA JAIN: so th govt. shld b able to provide it
vyankatesh rathi: u cant expect govt to install new transformers wvery now and thn
snowman2cool: they do baby
vyankatesh rathi: neither do relinace will install new transformers every now and thn
snowman2cool: they do it
vyankatesh rathi: govt is tryin
snowman2cool: government employess have realised the compettion
vyankatesh rathi: it needs people support
PRERNA JAIN: ok lets tk the eg. of railways
snowman2cool: take an exmple of MTNL it is the best..... look at thier prices... less than any private players
PRERNA JAIN: they r gettin crowded day by days
snowman2cool: railways is not an exmple
vyankatesh rathi: if public dont coo-operate how wil govt deliver service
snowman2cool: right gaurang
PRERNA JAIN: wht is th govt. doin for it?
snowman2cool: rav*
vyankatesh rathi: govt is installin new lines
snowman2cool: govt is squeezing itself to fit in
snowman2cool: lol
vyankatesh rathi: tracks
vyankatesh rathi: if u see between kalyan and thane
snowman2cool: new tracks.. new coaches
PRERNA JAIN: if this had would b th case
snowman2cool: w8 else du want
vyankatesh rathi: to incrse trains
vyankatesh rathi: ya
snowman2cool: only problem is shitty public
vyankatesh rathi: right
PRERNA JAIN: then u would hv never hear th news of daily accidents which take place
vyankatesh rathi: mentality of people has to chng
snowman2cool: migrating from any corner to find luck and these squatters ruin the whole infrastructure
Gd taker: now i would like u people to conclude one-by-one....
snowman2cool: Keep profitable PSU's and sell the Loss making ones !!!!!! thats all
vyankatesh rathi: just chng the mentality of public and turn loss makin psu in profitable ones
PRERNA JAIN: i hv never find th govt. of india efficient as it is corrupt.
PRERNA JAIN: So its better tht v give crucial sectors to private
PRERNA JAIN: so tht people cn get beter quality, hidh std. of living & multiple chices
take care
Best Regards,
Nikhil Gadodia
Consultant --> To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 0 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
Consultant --> To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 0 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
My Blogs
HR Related : To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 0 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
Mixture : To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 0 or greater. You currently have 0 posts. | | |  | | MBA Help | | RAM Your Friendly Helper
Specialisation:MBA Rep Power: 10 ![BMS MBA Helper[/url]](http://www.managementparadise.com/forums/images/reputation/reputation_pos.gif) | MBA Helper Hello, This is RAM (Robot Automated Message). It may take a while for the MP community to reply to YOUR message. By the time, use the Search Option below to get more information related to your topic If You Are New to the Forum, Click Here for NEWBIE's Guide to MP ! , Follow the Rules and Check the FAQs . Hope You Enjoy your Stay . Help Others Help Yourself ! PS: DO NOT POST FOR THANKING A USER, CLICK ON THE THANKS BUTTON INSTEAD | | | | | MP future GURU Institute: University of Mumbai
Status: Offline Posts: 1,249 Management Paradise Rupees.: 20,582 Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Mumbai | Re: GD-2 --->> PSU Disinvestment. -
February 5th, 2006
RESULTS--->>
This GD was better than the first one..
People did put in some relevant points.. but also went out of the topic too..
I can consider Prerna & Snowman2cool for the next round..
But as there were less number of people (only 3), this situation cannot be accepted.
Then too there should be relevane to be added to the GD....
I would request all the people to come in & gain more & more knowledge..
If they have any feedback... do post it.. & also if there are any suggestions, do let us know the same
People coming in GD are again requested to ''AVOID ONE LINERS''... make statements & then pass it.. we understand that it takes time, but then too..
take care
Best Regards,
Nikhil Gadodia
Consultant --> To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 0 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
Consultant --> To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 0 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
My Blogs
HR Related : To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 0 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
Mixture : To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 0 or greater. You currently have 0 posts. | | | | | | | | Trainee Manager
Status: Offline Posts: 2 Management Paradise Rupees.: -2,130 Join Date: Jan 2006 | Re: GD-2 --->> PSU Disinvestment. -
February 12th, 2006
Quote: |
Originally Posted by nick18_in Hi all..
For this gd there were only 3 people... so it dint took much time to declare the same...
I would again request people to be on time to enter the gd & please read the guideliness before coming in...
---------->>>>>
Gd taker: we start with intro.. frm all the people.. as education, exp..
snowman2cool: Rochit from TYBMS Lala College
vyankatesh rathi: vyankatesh from TYBMS SMT.C.H.M COLLEGE, ULHASNAGAR
PRERNA JAIN: Prerna from FYBMS MITHIBAI COLLEGE, VILE PARLE
Gd taker: the topic for todays gd is --->> PSU DISINVESTMENT
vyankatesh rathi: psu disinvestment
PRERNA JAIN: I think this year the govt. should concentrate on tha PSU disinvestment coz disinvestment in PSU helps in deepening and widening the domestic capital market
vyankatesh rathi: can u elaborate
vyankatesh rathi: prerna
PRERNA JAIN: Also, it will help in releasing huge amount of money that can be used for social as well as infrastructure projects.
snowman2cool: newayz Psu disinvestment has two sides
vyankatesh rathi: all things hav two sides
vyankatesh rathi: but disinvstng profitable units will not help
snowman2cool: psu disinvestment is like our government sold the navratnas the main companies which made profits to private players
vyankatesh rathi: thts wht i said
PRERNA JAIN: so what!
snowman2cool: so the governmet is controlling them we are at the rpivate players mercy
PRERNA JAIN: but u shld also look to th =ve points of it.
snowman2cool: positive or negative
PRERNA JAIN: +ve*
snowman2cool: positive or negative
snowman2cool: ok
vyankatesh rathi: wht are positive points
snowman2cool: more productivity
PRERNA JAIN: price reduction
snowman2cool: increased profits
PRERNA JAIN: better quality
snowman2cool: increased competitiveness
vyankatesh rathi: but wht if thy turn blind eye
vyankatesh rathi: to all these
PRERNA JAIN: reduced monopoly
vyankatesh rathi: and use it for their benefits
snowman2cool: but
snowman2cool: there is a catch
vyankatesh rathi: wht
PRERNA JAIN: this has never happened yet
vyankatesh rathi: it may be going on
snowman2cool: we are increasing our economy by doing so
vyankatesh rathi: its just its not yet publishd
snowman2cool: but there are staff reduction...
vyankatesh rathi: ya
vyankatesh rathi: thy cuttin down jobs
snowman2cool: more unemployment
vyankatesh rathi: see the negative points
snowman2cool: we are at thier mercy
vyankatesh rathi: whts the use of growin econmy ifits does not benefit the people
snowman2cool: we want power then calll reliance
snowman2cool: reliance cuts power wait for them
snowman2cool: government does not cut power !!
vyankatesh rathi: and thy dont respond fast
PRERNA JAIN: do u think if the govt. gives employment, then these employed people r workin properly?
vyankatesh rathi: govt does cut power
snowman2cool: see employment is another issue
vyankatesh rathi: who told private employees wrk properly
PRERNA JAIN: they do work coz they hv pressure of the work to get done from their superiors.
snowman2cool: but they hav the responsibility.... i hav seen public company employees getting things done
PRERNA JAIN: howeverin th public sec. they dont.
snowman2cool: working is not the issue
vyankatesh rathi: but if superiors wrk for thwir benefit thn whts the use disinvstn profitable units
snowman2cool: the main thing is
vyankatesh rathi: psu shuld not be disinvstd
PRERNA JAIN: ok then y do u think the govt. transferred the energy sector to ambani's?
vyankatesh rathi: just their shuld be a proper management in those units so as thy wrk properly
snowman2cool: psu divestment is harmful to our society becos as private player bring in efficiency they cut down staff which leads to unemployment..... our INDIA is overspilling... people are more.... they need food
PRERNA JAIN: bcoz private sector gives better results thn th public ones
snowman2cool: we need labour intensive companies
snowman2cool: rethe yhan machine intensive
vyankatesh rathi: i agree snowoman
PRERNA JAIN: but i dont
vyankatesh rathi: and prerna thts wht im sayin
vyankatesh rathi: see reliance do not provide electricity properly
snowman2cool: psu's no thwe responsibility towards the society.. the public.. they are answerable to the public
but private players are not answerable to anyoone ...... THIS IS THE POINT
PRERNA JAIN: it does
vyankatesh rathi: well thn y do we hear news
vyankatesh rathi: about irregular supply of electricty
vyankatesh rathi: and overchrgin of bills
vyankatesh rathi: prerna
PRERNA JAIN: then y wer there power failures in the rural areas?
snowman2cool: listen i live in mumbai i dont experience any problems regarding anything whatsoever but look at a different point of view look at thane etc
PRERNA JAIN: after when reliance has entered , it has made an attempt to reduce this
vyankatesh rathi: power failures are causd due to ever incrsin dmnd of electricity
snowman2cool: ya
PRERNA JAIN: so th govt. shld b able to provide it
vyankatesh rathi: u cant expect govt to install new transformers wvery now and thn
snowman2cool: they do baby
vyankatesh rathi: neither do relinace will install new transformers every now and thn
snowman2cool: they do it
vyankatesh rathi: govt is tryin
snowman2cool: government employess have realised the compettion
vyankatesh rathi: it needs people support
PRERNA JAIN: ok lets tk the eg. of railways
snowman2cool: take an exmple of MTNL it is the best..... look at thier prices... less than any private players
PRERNA JAIN: they r gettin crowded day by days
snowman2cool: railways is not an exmple
vyankatesh rathi: if public dont coo-operate how wil govt deliver service
snowman2cool: right gaurang
PRERNA JAIN: wht is th govt. doin for it?
snowman2cool: rav*
vyankatesh rathi: govt is installin new lines
snowman2cool: govt is squeezing itself to fit in
snowman2cool: lol
vyankatesh rathi: tracks
vyankatesh rathi: if u see between kalyan and thane
snowman2cool: new tracks.. new coaches
PRERNA JAIN: if this had would b th case
snowman2cool: w8 else du want
vyankatesh rathi: to incrse trains
vyankatesh rathi: ya
snowman2cool: only problem is shitty public
vyankatesh rathi: right
PRERNA JAIN: then u would hv never hear th news of daily accidents which take place
vyankatesh rathi: mentality of people has to chng
snowman2cool: migrating from any corner to find luck and these squatters ruin the whole infrastructure
Gd taker: now i would like u people to conclude one-by-one....
snowman2cool: Keep profitable PSU's and sell the Loss making ones !!!!!! thats all
vyankatesh rathi: just chng the mentality of public and turn loss makin psu in profitable ones
PRERNA JAIN: i hv never find th govt. of india efficient as it is corrupt.
PRERNA JAIN: So its better tht v give crucial sectors to private
PRERNA JAIN: so tht people cn get beter quality, hidh std. of living & multiple chices
take care | as far as disinvestment of PSU are concerned, i personally feel that the navratnas should be completely owned by the govt. (no disinvestment in these units)... as far as other profit making or sick PSU are concerned they should be disinvested... as i think govt. is here for regulating and maintaining law.. and not doing business and filling their pockets.. to that extent that they can feed their coming 7 generations. | | | | | The Following User Says Thank You to kukreja86@yahoo.com For This Useful Post: | | | | | | Trainee Manager Institute: CBS
Status: Offline Posts: 3 Management Paradise Rupees.: 275 Join Date: Oct 2009 | Re: GD-2 --->> PSU Disinvestment. -
October 10th, 2009
I think the govt should clearly look at the budget and then decide the level of disinvestlment | | | |
| Thread Tools | | | | Display Modes |  Linear Mode |
Posting Rules
| You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off
| | |
|
Members: 161,473
Threads: 159,836
Posts: 322,906
Top Poster: MP-ROBOT (18,260)
| | Welcome to our newest member, nishad k.p |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.3 Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.3.0
vBulletin Skin developed by: vBStyles.com
ManagementParadise is not responsible for the views and opinion of the posters. The posters and only posters shall be liable for any copyright infringement.
|  |
